Mister Magic

Kiersten White

Reviewed 02-03-2024

A story with a lot of heart and great messaging. Most characters have well-developed backstories and their interactions feel genuine, minus one relationship that kind of just happens. I really enjoyed the thought concepts presented throughout, the longing for a simpler time, inability to find a place or purpose, and feeling like you should be something more. Each of the main cast has a different struggle and I related to more than a couple of them at times. Finding a way to deal with your issues is important and the camaraderie you can find when opening up to others helps a ton. This group works together on their problems, which is a central theme to the novel. Asking for help from those you trust is never a bad thing. It is almost impossible to do everything on your own, because humans are hardwired to crave interaction with one another. You are not weak for asking for help or knowing your limits. It is a sign of strength to be able to acknowledge you are not capable of everything on your own and lean on those that you mutually care for. These ideas help to deepen the relationships of the characters so you can feel the genuine emotional interactions between them.

As for the side characters, there wasn’t much to them. Their motivations for doing what they do are basic and were used as a plot device more than anything. The motivations were unrealistic and they all felt more like cartoon villains than a substantial threat, plus they came out of left field. It would have been better if they had stayed in the background and had nothing to do with Mister Magic. Mister Magic himself was a whole other concept.

The main aspect of his creation I would have preferred to leave out as it was unnecessary. It did however tie back to the reasoning for the entire goings-on. That central reason is relatively flimsy, even with the explanation of him, but the focus of the fiction is on the characters’ journeys and struggles, which it heartily delivers on. It is an easy read, not relying on setting the stage, but allowing the characters to be the focal point. I enjoyed this story. There were some moments where I laughed and others where I felt my heart grow heavy. I had a nightmare about this book, but I still recommend it! I look forward to reading more of her works if this is how much heart she puts into them.

  • The town’s entire reasoning for trying to bring back Mister Magic was misbehaving children? That is a ridiculous motivator! I could not believe that was why they brought the cast of the show back. A better plot device would have been that the power of Mister Magic becoming unstable was threatening the town, which is a subplot that’s half mentioned. This would’ve been way better as the focus, because you could have reluctant townspeople just trying to protect each other by sacrificing the main cast. It would have been a better dynamic.

    Mister Magic being Jenny’s dad was also kind of thrown in. It felt unnecessary because nothing really came of it. If White had done something more with the idea, I would have appreciated this detail more.

    Javi and Marcus also was not a well-developed relationship, which is strange given the amount of character depth we see throughout. That alone felt haphazardly thrown in and I personally did not feel like it was earned.

    Our main girl taking Mister Magic’s place was basically a given as soon as the book started, but still felt impactful because of the waste of potential. She never really got to live her own life and that’s tragic. Val was a tragic hero in the end, because she knew her friends had entire lives to go back to and she didn’t.

    I still enjoyed this book and I think it’s worth a read if not just for the messaging.

What are your thoughts?